• 0 Posts
  • 30 Comments
Joined 13 days ago
cake
Cake day: November 5th, 2026

help-circle



  • I don’t see it as a similar black hole

    US AI investment last year was roughly $290 billion. China’s was $12 billion. That’s a 23 to 1 ratio. And yet the actual output is nearly identical based on Stanford HAI’s 2026 AI Index

    Presumably people will need ram, motherboards, GPU’s, CPU’s, and rare earth metals even when this bubble pops, no?

    AI still does have utility as we see in China with it’s incorporation into things like their factories, driverless infrastructure, academic research, military spending, and probably most important for China: assissting with their more centrally planned economy. Which all gives them a tangible competitive edge and helps grow other businesses as well.

    In Shenzhen, I toured Huawei Technologies’ assembly line for its newest Mate 90 smartphones. Zha Jun, who oversees Huawei’s research and development, explained that this line used to have 86 workers per shift — doing mostly manual inspections — and the rest of the work force was robots. It recently shrank that to nine people by turning to A.I.-enabled image recognition systems.

    When I asked what kind of data center it used to run the A.I. systems, Zha said: “We have no need for a data center. Huawei can get all the A.I. benefits it needs for these kinds of manufacturing improvements using our own open-weight, domain-specific A.I. models with less than one billion parameters.” Those are the ones with circuitry that amounts to the size of a small suitcase. (Parameters are a measure of the connections and weights that an A.I. model uses to process information and are used as a general proxy for its complexity and capacity to learn.) These small A.I. models, Zha added, were “good enough” to make big improvements in manufacturing.

    American AI companies are trying to put enclosures around knowledge itself and charge everyone rent for access, fostering a codependency and then profiting off being it’s gatekeeper(and increasingly root themselves into government functions to extract lucrative one sided deals). This was the classic Uber/Amazon strategy of trying to debt finance your way into market monopoly to create a techno fiefdom you then have immense control over not just your direct business, but others as well. Which also means they either need to cartelize or it incentivizes a race to be the best frontier model and become the dominant player while doing this circular financing game. All for a product they can’t find profitability from as they envision and is far more problematic as a replacement for white collar work then they envisioned(now one off ramp would also be a controlled bubble demolition and bail out, which I wouldn’t rule out happening and seemingly many investors are investing based on that assumption).

    Look at China in literally every other domain they have come to dominate. They build the foundation. Focus on establishing vertically integrated supply chains, build domestic manufacturing capacity usually centering critical components. Form an entire industrial ecosystem around that domain. Then they leverage industrial policy, public financing, economies of scale, and competition to drive down costs and diffuse that technology throughout the economy and then export it abroad.


  • People hate that though…

    A major reason places like Reddit and FB persist despite enshitification is cause of the shared space

    The reason the Fediverse is the way it is is to create a shared ecosystem through open sourcing.

    A major appeal of things like Apple is the easy to use cohesive ecosystem.

    You can play a podcast on your phone, keep listening on your laptop, then cast it to your screen in the car.

    People don’t want to juggle 10 different independent OS’s between their car, their partner’s car, their phone, their laptop, and their work. And no one wakes up being like I want worse, more expensive, more convoluted driverless car tech that will struggle to scale outside major cities.

    The problem is that like I said, no individual company can actually produce it, and if they did that would be a problem of monopoly. This is why you need actual industrial policy, long-term planning, and most importantly, control over those productive forces.



  • In large part cause of protectionism…I literally can not buy and register and insure a Chinese vehicle in my state.

    Look up China’s Vehicle–Road–Cloud Integration, that is the sort of stuff I am talking about WRT to this discussion on AI innovation.

    It is a centrally planned industrial policy plan that merges BeiDou satellite navigation, connected and integrated with traffic signals, roadside sensors built into city and highway infastructure, 5G networks, cloud computing, open weight AI models, and establishes common technical standards so vehicles can communicate with their surrounding infrastructure.

    Again, this is the secret sauce, not who has the individually best frontier tech in a specific domain.

    No individual automaker, regardless of how innovative or well-capitalized, can independently develop the satellite networks, municipal infrastructure, communications standards, and public computing systems necessary to realize the full potential of these technologies.

    And they aren’t reinventing the wheel here, this sort of managed economic planning built America, built Japan, built Taiwan, and is building China.

    And what China is developing toward is to essentially then export some or all of this innovation abroad.


  • I think this fundamentally misses some important context though.

    China’s goal is not to try and out compete on having the most advanced proprietary model so they can put enclosures around their tech and charge rents. Then prop up the profits of a handful of companies with elaborate circular funding schemes and gatekeeping protectionism.

    China envisions AI as a open weight, widely distributable, customizable, general-purpose technology that can be integrated throughout its entire economy(and the rest of the world). The goal is to diffuse the technology as broadly as possible, drive down the cost of adoption, and build an entire industrial ecosystem around it.

    And that is not the whole strategy but one component.

    China’s top priority in their recent 5 year plan is not to develop the most advanced frontier model, it’s to dramatically improve and scale up the production of computer components like advanced RAM, GPU’s, and the broad hardware supply chain for AI.

    Anyone that has ever messed with local LLM’s knows how intensive that is.

    So on the one end you have people like Altman saying they want to take ram and gpus out of consumer’s hands, put up massive protectionism, and regulate access so they can be the feudal lords over their proprietary tech and extract rents.

    On the other side is China chasing a strategy of making AI models cheaper, more accessible, and more customizable, while simultaneously investing in the domestic industrial capacity to manufacture the hardware needed to run them.

    To me China is making the wiser, more holistic, and long term sustainable bet.


  • China did to US AI companies what US AI companies did to everyone else on the planet.

    Pretty sure this was largely known almost from the jump?

    Deepseek’s first public model was basically just a reverse engineered ChatGPT model with modifications.

    I disagree with the rest though.

    The Chinese only know how to copy and scale, not innovate.

    China is so far ahead of actually automating and finding practical uses for AI tech that this is absurd.

    Have you looked up their dark factories or how their vehicle tech and GPS is way ahead of the US?

    China, ironically, is fostering a culture and market around AI tech that the US once built it’s initial advantages with. Which was move fast, open source(including when someone doesn’t want their IP open sourced), leverage state research that can be merged into private enterprise(see Google), and foster open competition chained to a egalitarian ethos of improving lives not just profits(even if this part was always largely bullshit once companies like Google stopped promising to do no evil and became prisoners to the line must go up problem).

    Versus American AI that which is increasingly organized around enclosure, proprietary control, and rent extraction.

    And your embrace of open weight AI models sort of suggests why China IMO is picking the right path and why I said what I said.


  • Many in the MSM reported this over a year ago.

    This is going viral cause it now serves a political purpose in different corners of the oligarchy.

    Rubio cause he is a true believer Neocon Cold War shill(Rubio is who leaked the now disputed notion Jensen was being honeypotted by a Chinese spy) and most of the AI companies want to put a protective moat around their AI so they can cartelize the tech and it’s various inputs going into it. using the most powerful government in the world to enforce it. Nvidia was the central power agent in the middle that has an incentive in the other direction to want a more open AI market where they can sell their chips anywhere.

    So deploy the China boogieman and then pressure US and US allies to refuse any adoption of China’s open weight models and restrict supply chains(something we are actively doing as we speak) and watch as the broad masses go along with new regulations and restrictions serving the AI companies interests in the name of security/safety and conservatives cheer on taking it to the Chinese and liberals cheer it on in the name of “accountability” for Trump’s corruption and punishing Nvidia for breaking (questionable) US law on sales to China…Or just cause they are distracted with the shiny drama of Jensen being the one oligarch seemingly hooking up with age appropriate women

    Don’t believe me? WSJ reports Commerce is about to name a list of favored ai companies (openai, anthropic, microsoft, amazon amongst others) as “national champions.” Qualifying them for special treatment and support by the US government: faster export licenses, government backing abroad(fancy way of saying using the power and threat of US might to advance their interests), federal financing, regulatory protection, and stricter import/export controls.

    I think it’s ultimately a sign of weakness(and a bit of face saving for the grifters) and I personally think China has already won this space, but there is very much still a world where the US, in a seemingly bipartisan fashion, is going to build protectionism around this tech to try and prop it up at the expense of everything else.





  • Nola@piefed.ziptoLemmy Shitpost@lemmy.world•Putin too, for some reason
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    6 days ago

    I don’t think lynchings have been the only way human groups have dealt with crimes against innocents though, historically or presently.

    And most of what you are talking about is behavior under capitalist or feudalist systems.

    And most crime under those systems is born out of poverty.

    I have not heard of the Zapatista’s engaging in routine lynchings for example. The biggest threats to them have not been irrational lynch parties inside their society, it had been the capitalist forces outside of it trying to violently conquer them.

    And again, I am not an anarchist, so I feel weird trying to speak too deeply past my own understanding of their positions or things I have some crossover beliefs in as well.


  • I mean this is sort of backdooring itself into the trove of arguments and theory around why a communist revolution has to be an international liberation movement, and why you need a revolutionary vanguard cause you can’t hope to achieve communism while capitalist imperialism is still around.

    Which is precisely why the question of socialism/communism or Anarchism and how to achieve it goes beyond just seizing control of the state or reorganizing production and the relationship with the state within national borders. It’s also became heavily about surviving and overcoming an international system of capitalist power that has both the material incentive and institutional capacity to prevent those alternatives from succeeding.


  • Nola@piefed.ziptoLemmy Shitpost@lemmy.world•Putin too, for some reason
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    6 days ago

    I don’t think many anarchists are arguing for societies comprised of a billion people…Almost like they are explicitly wanting to go in the opposite direction and eliminate such a state.

    And just again for clarity, I am not an anarchist, but I also think it’s silly to get this worked up over an ideology it’s not even clear people have ever spent any time trying to understand in good faith.


  • Nola@piefed.ziptoLemmy Shitpost@lemmy.world•Putin too, for some reason
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    8
    ·
    6 days ago

    Cause you said they all devolved into dictatorships and that is factually inaccurate.

    Every example in the OP is from a revolution that occurred in response to an existing non-democratic, capitalist, authoritarian state.

    So the revolutions took over states that were in fact not democratic. This is not a moral judgement but a clarification of fact.

    Another clarification is the notion of “Have Always”

    Do you think those listed are the only examples?

    Care to explain the Paris Commune? Allende in Chile? The socialist republic in Spain? Arbenz in Guatemala? Lumumba and the pan african movement in Congo? Nicaragua? The PKI and Sukarmo in Indonesia? And then in East Timor? Just to name a few

    It is not a whataboutism to challenge your assertions of factual ignorance.



  • Nola@piefed.ziptoLemmy Shitpost@lemmy.world•Putin too, for some reason
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    6 days ago

    This is a society that is built around a system of forced for-profit market dependency that puts ownership enclosures over the land, commons, and productive forces into the hands of a small percentage of private capital owners then relies upon the forced dispossession of people from direct access to the means of subsistence (land, tools, resources) in order to create a class of individuals with no alternative but to sell their labor for a wage on the market so they can purchase the means of survival.

    And that in order to enforce that requires a powerful state capable of using violence when necessary to uphold that.

    So yeah, remove the enforcers and that system is likely to break down and a lot of people are going to try and loot and take what they need that they currently don’t have for survival in the short term.

    It would also likely trigger our innate communal cooperative nature that has been key to our survival and evolution as a species.

    I’m not personally an anarchist but I think you might be guilty of many of the things you accuse others of here.


  • Nola@piefed.ziptoLemmy Shitpost@lemmy.world•Putin too, for some reason
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    6 days ago

    I’m not even an anarchist but this is pretty easy to simply look at history and answer

    It would be like most tribal societies throughout human history. Where small to even very large societal level groups rely upon a economic and social system of mutualism/reciprocity, central planning, and social standing.

    People that are able and refuse to contribute would receive little beyond their basic needs, likely socially pilloried, or in extreme cases be asked to leave. And violence against innocents would be punished like in any society.

    Like the one thing almost every single human society we have had evidence for it’s social structure has had a version of the Golden Rule.